welcome

Parents of lost babies and potential of all kinds: come here to share the technicolour, the vividness, the despair, the heart-broken-open, the compassion we learn for others, having been through this mess — and see it reflected back at you, acknowledged, understood.

subscribe
search
Powered by Squarespace
« on survival | Main | No News »
Thursday
Nov262009

gratitude

It’s gut wrenching how much I long for her these days.

A whirl of small brown leaves flies against the windshield of my car as I drive by their tree, almost bare.

Hello, Beautiful…

I feel her close, I really do.

And also, deep in my gut, everywhere in my heart, in all of me – the awareness that my child in her body is missing.

For about a month, we’ve had her picture close by in the dining room of our new home. It’s in a temporary frame… I’m working on something much more grand, much more beautiful. But her sweetest face is there in all its 8x10 glory, peeking out at us as we eat, draw, do homework, putz around on the computer, talk. As I write this.

There she is… and yet that’s not her. It’s just her photograph. Sometimes I feel her there. Sometimes she is in the leaves. Sometimes in the occasional milkweed seed that reminds me of the oh-so-sad-so-terribly-incredibly-painfully-sad week we spent in the mountains after we said goodbye to her. Sometimes in the red tail hawk that flies above Cincinnati, though much less frequently than she did in San Francisco.

When I look at that photograph, I just miss my Baby Girl… in the flesh.

I am reminded each time I look at it just how beautiful she was. And how much she struggled with each breath. That’s when the tears come, when I remember those days in between,

She’s doing surprisingly well… this is what she’ll need in order to come home,

and,

She just can’t get enough air into her small fragile lungs, even with all this support.

That’s when I imagine what it would be like now if things hadn’t turned, if she had come home on oxygen and continued to get stronger.

*****

I know how lucky I am that I got to know her when she was alive. I know how lucky I am that I got to hold her, to kiss her, to sing to her, to touch her soft skin, to look into her eyes as she looked into mine. I know we didn’t all get that in this community of deadbabyparents… I wish we all had. I wish all of our babies were still here, in the flesh, alive and well.

Maybe I have more photos of my baby, but it doesn’t make it easier to have lost her. Nothing can make it easy to lose a child. Easy isn’t a word I identify with anymore. As a word, it feels trivial and doesn’t serve me much. But hard… that feels too simplistic. Sometimes it isn’t hard. Sometimes it just is.

Strange feels more like it these days. Strange because I can simultaneously feel acceptance and disbelief. So many days that is my normal. I still say to Tikva, several times a week, silently or out loud,

Oh Baby Girl… you died. You died.

Then a voice within me will remember, will insist,

But you lived, too. I won’t ever forget that you lived. And for that, I am grateful.

It may have been a blink of an eye, like a daydream… but I wouldn’t trade it in for forgetting the loss of you. Not ever.

*****

I was terrified last year at this time to spend Thanksgiving with our family. I was terrified to be up close and personal with Tikva’s cousin, who was born during the weeks in between my daugther’s birth and her death. I was so scared of being face to face with the reminder that my baby wasn’t there, that he was here and she was not. The fear became something bigger than itself, and I almost spent Thanksgiving separate from my entire family.

But in the end I went. And I sat with this beautiful little boy on my lap, felt his newness, looked into his big brown eyes that reminded me of Tikva’s. And I saw his bright soul, felt his pureness. The ease of being with an uncomplicated soul that a baby is. Connected to him as his own self, not as a reminder of what I didn’t have. He had no idea that he had a cousin who died shortly after he was born. One day he will, and forever he will remind me of the age Tikva would be if only…

But in that moment he was just pure love. And I let myself take that in.

And I looked around at my family all over the house, watching football, taking one more bite of pie while talking and drinking coffee. And I felt so deeply grateful for every single one of them who had held me together before, during and since Tikva’s life. The loss of the months leading up to last Thanksgiving didn’t take away my gratitude for all that remained.

I felt I was still here because of them. Because of my husband and my incredible and brave older daughter, my Dahlia. Because of my sister and my father and my family and my friends – my community. Because of my city, my ocean, my park to walk in, my hawks flying above. My yoga classes to cry silently in. My work to go to for a day’s worth of distraction from my thoughts, and time to read a babylost blog when I needed to go in.

And because of this place I stumbled upon in the early months after Tikva’s death. Where I breathed a sigh of relief that I wasn’t alone, and soon felt the uncomfortable mingling of that relief with the realization that the only way I could not feel alone here was for other parents to also have lost their babies. Where you just get it without my having to explain.

Thank you.

*****

I’m not much for holidays honoring consumerism and the massacre indigenous peoples. I’m not a huge fan of turkey and the gluttony that accompanies this holiday, especially when I know that many of us aren’t blessed to eat every day, much less such a feast. But I do get swept up – just a little – in taking pause for gratitude.

For me, gratitude after loss is different. It’s too simple to say that because of all I have lost, I appreciate what I have so much more. It has something to do with the impossible-to-shake-now-and-probably-forever recognition of just how fragile it all is… that all I really have, no matter how much time I get here, together with those I cherish, is this moment I am in. That understanding just doesn’t let go of me, and neither does the gratefulness I feel that seems to go hand in hand with it.

Because if all I have is this moment, then I better kiss my Dahlia one extra time today, better eat that last piece of dark chocolate waiting for me in the cookie jar, better call my dad to tell him I love him, better tell my husband one more time just how proud I am of him… and I better be kind and gentle with myself.

*****

Thank you, Tikva, for awakening me to the present moment more than anyone ever has. Because with you, I could do nothing greater than be completely present – unconditionally – for as long as we would get together.

And beyond.

.::.

How does gratitude feel to you now? Is it there? The same? Different? If you do feel it, what makes you feel grateful?

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (12)

"Strange feels more like it these days. Strange because I can simultaneously feel acceptance and disbelief. So many days that is my normal. I still say to Tikva, several times a week, silently or out loud,

Oh Baby Girl… you died. You died.

Then a voice within me will remember, will insist,

But you lived, too. I won’t ever forget that you lived. And for that, I am grateful."

I can't say it any better than that. That mix of acceptance and disbelief... two and a half years out, that is my every single day. Strange that those two things can coexist.

Before losing Liam, I didn't have much need for gratitude. Does that make sense? I'd never faced anything more difficult than a jellyfish sting. The possibility of loss or serious suffering had never really occurred to me. Not *really*. Not seriously. And I don't know that you can be truly grateful unless that gratitude is informed with an intimate experience of all that could (and can, and does) derail what we love and want most in our lives.

That makes me sound like a gratitude elitist, I know. I don't know what to do about that. I'd never undermine the emotion of gratitude in anyone else of any other stripe, but this is how it was for me. Before Liam and Ben were born, I thought I knew what fear was. And hope, and love, and despair. And gratitude.

I didn't. Not until that day.
November 26, 2009 | Unregistered Commentersweetsalty kate
I keep wanting to feel grateful today but just can't. Not this year. Not when my son should be in my arms for his first Thanksgiving.

But then I'm hit by sheer gratitude--a kind of loosening of the body to breathe, as if coming home from the party and being allowed, finally, to take off the ridiculous party dress--for women and men who understand, for those who are there, as you said, "when I needed to go in." Thank you for opening the door on this Thanksgiving night and giving me shelter. It's been a sad day, and while the holiday with friends held long enough they are family provides some solace, there's also that terrible alone feeling that surrounds and wasn't letting go, and so I came here, and found this, and I know how very much I appreciate it, because it's missing everywhere else around.
November 26, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterC
I can't thank you enough for this post. I recognize my own feelings in each paragraph, and while it's wrenching to see your pain, it's also healing to know that I'm not alone on this path.

So much of life feels like a double-edged sword now. My deep gratitude for the 4 days I had with my Frannie and for my amazing 4-year-old daughter coexist alongside my pain and fear. In fact, I've come to think of them as inextricably linked. This is not a lens I would ever have asked for or wanted, but now that I have it, I'm thankful for all that I'm able to see with it.
November 27, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterLH
What a beautiful post Gal. I'm so sorry. That shuddering turn from 'coming home' to 'fragile lungs' made my stomach lurch reading it.

I think disbelief is still winning out for me. I still find myself saying 'I wish you hadn't died. How I wish you hadn't died.' But perhaps my acceptance is implicit in the 'wishing' of it even if I don't feel accepting yet.

I was so very, very pleased to meet my daughter. So pleased. Sometimes that is all I can remember about the three and a bit days that she was alive. The pleasure that I took in her existence, the love that I felt for her.

I will always be grateful to the medical staff that made her life a possibility, and to my daughter herself. I felt certain that she would not survive being born. I think (or hope) that I have been, and always will be, grateful for that. That those feelings will persist.

I can't imagine thinking of her without a little rush of pleasure and a little skip in my heart. Thinking of her, my daughter. Not her death. Not even her life which was short and painful. Just her.

I can't imagine picturing the doctors who worked around her with such concentration and tenderness without at least a touch of gratitude.

"To look life in the face, always, to look life in the face, and to know it for what it is...at last, to love it for what it is, and then to put it away.” Virgina Woolf

I think that Georgina's life, her death and Jessica's long NICU stay forced me to 'look life in the face, and to know it for what it is.'
The loving part . . .well, I'm working on it.
It has certainly helped me to face the prospect of 'putting it away', something I was somewhat cowardly about prior to losing her.

My life prior to Georgina's death contained no real hardship or pain. Not even a jellyfish sting like Kate's. It was, in many ways, a narrow little life. Led by a stupid, self-satisfied woman. But I sometimes miss being that person. It is hard to be thankful for knowledge that is imparted to you in such a painful and forceful way. But perhaps I need to work on that too.
November 27, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterCatherine W
I'm here now, in Cape Cod, a post-Thanksgiving glow, with Bob's family. Everything seems so... normal. Young adults & 4 kids, laughing, fighting, playing ping pong, eating (a lot). We went to a Celtic's game in Boston & while it was out of my usual element, there was so much life there-- so many people just really happy to be a part of this whole network of people-- This life force continues to pulse through us & this weekend, with these healthy people, safe and warm, I am grateful.
November 28, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterElizheva
Beautiful and thought-provoking as always.

I do feel gratitude. Not always or constantly, as demonstrated this weekend with the in-laws. Then it was disbelief and anger, because there was no acknowledgement of my son, or of our grief, or that I had ever been pregnant in the first time I have seen them since losing Gabriel. Not even a low-voiced and concern-crinkle-eyed 'How are you doing?' embued with meaning. I remember getting into the car when the meal was over and venting a ton of anger at them towards my husband (all couched around other things - how they treated my SIL, what they said about her boyfriend, how they spoke of my nephew, etc) and finally hitting a red light and turning to my husband and saying, "They do know that we had a son, right? That he died, right? Like, three months ago? I didn't just imagine him, did I?" And he let out a breath and said, "No you didn't, but I was starting to wonder too."

Which leads me to say, I am grateful for my husband. Eternally, abidingly grateful for that wonderful man who has propped me up and held me up and wouldn't let me go. He is a better partner in life, even in tragedy, than I had any right to hope for or deserve.

I do see and feel gratitude differently. It's not constant yet, as I said above, but it's deeper and more meaningful. I can view my life and see not only the tragedy, but the beauty and the blessings, and I am acutely more aware of how fragile and transitory they can be. I do think tragedy tempers life and that experience can result in a greater appreciation of life for what it is. Not always, not for everyone. The first pregnancy losses did not do that - they only provoked bitterness and anger that I was denied what we wanted. Gabriel is the one who taught me gratitude and I am grateful for him beyond what words can describe - grateful for his short life, grateful to share him with my husband, grateful to have seen him and held him and know that he was born alive, grateful that he died in our arms and not on a sterile triage table, grateful to have been and to be his mother. Despite the enormous amounts of pain we've lived through because of these things, I am grateful for my son.
November 30, 2009 | Unregistered Commentereliza
Oh, and also? What you've said about seeing Tikva in the leaves and in the hawk? Me too. I feel Gabriel around me, feel his smile, hear the ghost of a whisper of laughter as my cursor on the computer moves without me touching it. I feel him in the breeze, in a butterfly from nowhere that flutters by without warning. Learning that he isn't gone, that he is still there, letting us know that, that my husband had/has the same experiences . . . that we both feel his presence . . . it is such a comfort. Such a relief.
November 30, 2009 | Unregistered Commentereliza
i was grateful too. grateful in the moment - beyond grateful, full of wonder even as it all condensed down to hours, simply because there he WAS, my child - and grateful now. for what he taught me and what his having been here continues to teach me.

sometimes i think i'm beyond it, it's been so long - that i'm past both the learning new things from the experience and just the visceral missing him, as you write of missing Tikva. but when i read your words i inhaled that sharp gasp that comes only when i'm caught off guard by something that i wasn't prepared for. i wasn't prepared to remember what it feels like to miss Finn with my skin...but i do. wow. all this time, and just for a second you opened a tiny window where i felt him again, the missing piece of him.

it's been long enough, Gal, that the missing of that missing piece - the simple absence - has become normal. so to feel it was to feel him. and thus a great gift, a gift i am thankful for. more than i can say.
November 30, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterBon
I'm more thankful than I've ever been this year, and it's in many ways a relief because last year at this time it was a real struggle to keep "Thanksgiving" from feeling like a gaping, mocking joke. I still had things to be thankful for, and I knew that, but it wasn't enough to buoy me up for long.

This year I can laugh, and mean it, and, as you've written so well, knowing how fragile everything is makes me appreciate the good things I have while I have them.
December 1, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterErica
I've only really started to feel grateful, but it's hard and I keep reminding myself that I need to remember all that's happened, so that I can move on.

Beautiful post.
December 2, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterSalma
I have to say in the almost 4 years since I lost my son I can't bear to celebrate Thanksgiving or Christmas. Maybe I never will. It seems so wrong without him. I now go out of town during the holidays to get away. And Eliza, I had the same thing happen with my in-laws. Not one word ever about our son. Everyone wants to pretend he didn't exist. Like he is a shameful secret. That cuts like a knife.
December 3, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterLu
We lost our daughter, our first child, Jasmine 17th February this year. She was born full term and perfect - a totally random situation in which her left arm caused her own asphyxiation just after my waters broke, caused her to die just before she was born. Unaware to all and sundry until we arrived at hospital when heart beat could not be found and consequently never was. So this is our first Christmas, here in Australia, without Jasmine and Saturday we will spend with my husand's family before some of them fly off to Sydney for Christams Day. I am grateful for your post as the whole Christmas 'thing' is the monster wave which suddenly crept up behind me and pulled me under again, last weekend. Slapped around the back of my head and dragged deep into another dimension of my grief.

Yes, I am grateful that the Psychologist told us that grief comes in waves, the day after Jasmine was born. Just about the only words I can remember her saying, that day. Grateful to be given the basic information that best describes the process and experince of my grief to date. I too have never experienced such presence, in my life, since losing Jasmine. Yes, I too know the fragility of life as we know it as I experience my own fragility, long buried and quite unrecognisable to me when she first surfaced. A part of myself I had worked hard at disquising over the years, but that which Jasmine had started to unveil through her physical presence as she grew inside me. But nowhere close to the levels and depths, since she died, and I m grateful to her for this and so much more. True strength in the presence of my own fragility, only fully experiencing and recognising one when I can hold the other. I hope I can hold the joy and pain on Saturday. Yes, I fear the day as my memories of last Christmas, big of belly and full of hopes and dreams that were all coming true. Presents for Jasmine before she was even born. Talk of how different the next Christmas would be as she would be 10 months old...how different....that's true. And yes, when another wave sucks me under, I again experience the full body, mind and spirit disbelief of how this could have happened and if I just allow the wave to take me in full, I rise to the surface again, a different woman again. Softer, stronger, more peaceful and more whole that I could have ever known, had Jasmine not died. So yes, the disbelief and acceptance do walk in parallels as does so much more of this mystery we call life.

Forced into a state of no meaning, my life gradually expands into deserts I knew not before but continue to navigate my way through. Today, this day and beyond, I continue to experience more meaning and love than I could have imagined before Jasmine died, and this was always a deeper desire of mine too.
Oceans and deserts, neither good nor bad. It's all matter of perspective really and that changes at any given moment, as life, as just is....
Our first Christmas and gratitude...I will seek tp try and onto to both and allow all that comes as a result.
Love and Light to all who know these spaces
December 17, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterDawn Murray

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.