welcome

Parents of lost babies and potential of all kinds: come here to share the technicolour, the vividness, the despair, the heart-broken-open, the compassion we learn for others, having been through this mess — and see it reflected back at you, acknowledged, understood.

subscribe
search
Powered by Squarespace
« call for nominations: glow in the woods awards winter 2008-09 | Main | Winceables »
Tuesday
10Feb2009

leavetaking

The little green box sits in a drawer now, a fine layer of dust collecting from god knows where. I do not open it anymore. I know he is not in there.

I thought I'd said goodbye long before I really did. The first time I held him, he was dying. And though I whispered, it's okay, it's alright little one, you can go, mama loves you, it's okay...I was only trying to ease the passage, make him feel safe since I could not keep him safe, since I could not keep him. But that was not goodbye...in my heart, I was still saying hello.

The last time I held him he had been dead twelve hours, lividity darkening one side of his small face. I waited for them to bring him to me, shy and eager as if before a date. I remember most the adrenalin taste of my anticipation, the leap in my heart even though I am a sane-ish sort and the joy I felt awaiting him feels ridiculous, even macabre in the recounting. But I did not believe he was alive: more that life and death were irrelevant, for a minute. It seemed enough that he was himself, and would be with me again. I think I thought that I wanted to say goodbye, though I couldn't have said those words aloud then...too maudlin. I think now that I was wrong, that goodbye was nowhere on my radar. I just wanted my baby. And I would want him with a keening ache for a long time after.

Our culture tells us that goodbye comes with death, or at the very latest with the last leavetaking of the body of the departed. The dead leave visible holes in the fabric of our lives, and we know them gone by the gaps.

But with babies, especially those who never came home at all, the thresholds are blurred. Waiting for a baby, a parent's life and selfhood shift to accommodate the coming addition...but the changes are private, woven in secret thread, invisible. When the baby dies, the leavetaking comes hand in hand with - or before, or in place of - that first magical hello, and all the anticipation and identity shifts of the parent-to-be are left hanging, shredded, irreconcilable with the fabric visible to the outside world. The usual rules of goodbye suggest that the absence of someone who was barely, in fact, present should be a simple thing.

But if it were, this corner of the internet would be a lonely place.

Pieces of goodbye crept up on me, crowded in. Each time I called him into being aloud, spoke the reality of his death, he slipped a little further from me. Each time realization fell and the obvious clicked: that I would never see what he would have looked like as a five year old, that I that there would never be a photo of all my children - if I eventually had other children - together. Each one tore at me, ripped open again the wound where all the futures I'd woven for us had been. Each one was invisible to the outside world, unremarkable to anyone who did not realize that my heart still held him whole long after his body had been relinquished to the fire. I knew he was gone, knew it in every part of me...my spread hips, my leaking breasts, my empty, searching hands. But it was the rituals of living without him that forced me to acknowledge what I knew, internalize it. Each time I moved forward without him, I let go a little. And I hated that. We had had so little time, he and I.

Then one day I opened the little green box to finger his small hat and when I held it to my face to breathe him in all I smelled was dust. No trace. And I sat, alert, surprised, as if suddenly realizing that he'd been gone a long time. I felt...odd, caught out...as if someone might be watching, as if I'd been discovered mothering a box.

are you there, little one?
I whispered.

No answer. And it all clicked into place.

I felt the shift deep inside me, just as I'd felt it all those months before as I waited for motherhood...the quiet sea change where what was once incomprehensible becomes, simply, who you are. Still a mother. To a child I'd never see again. There it was: goodbye.

And yet I felt him, too, closer then than I had in a long time, that brightness and sweetness of the moments holding him in my arms. you're gone, I said quietly. I miss you.

Did you say goodbye? All at once, or in pieces? What does goodbye mean, to you?

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

this is my own goodbye, of a sort...my last post as a regular contributor here at Glow.

i will be reading, still, walking alongside, but almost four years out from Finn's death i feel another shift taking place in me and the urgency i long felt to write it all out has waned.  i still miss him, but that missing has become something i want to sit quietly with for awhile, and let other voices rise here to continue weaving our song of Medusa-hood, of love and grief.

thank you, all of you, for making this place a community.

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (25)

But with babies, especially those who never came home at all, the thresholds are blurred. Waiting for a baby, a parent's life and selfhood shift to accommodate the coming addition...but the changes are private, woven in secret thread, invisible. When the baby dies, the leavetaking comes hand in hand with - or before, or in place of - that first magical hello, and all the anticipation and identity shifts of the parent-to-be are left hanging, shredded, irreconcilable with the fabric visible to the outside world. The usual rules of goodbye suggest that the absence of someone who was barely, in fact, present should be a simple thing.


Thank you for saying it, these are the words that describe me perfectly right now, and I couldn't find them.
February 10, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterKatherine
I really relate to this post. It perfectly describes things, to say that "waiting for a baby, a parent's life and selfhood shift to accommodate the coming addition...but the changes are private, woven in secret thread, invisible." And the part about moving forward without your baby. Especially when your body doesn't understand. . .

Thank you for your words.
February 10, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterBluebird
wow, Bon. a beautiful piece. your story of goodbye is a really strong perspective. i could picture all of it, your moments with him and your moments since, in the process of the goodbye. i feel a strange sense of relief for you that you are able to say goodbye to the need and want of writing about it cathartically, regularly. that sure means something. whatever it is, there is a sense of peace surrounding your words. thanks for sharing. ((hugs))
February 10, 2009 | Unregistered Commentercheerleader
Bon, this is such an incredible post, and such a tribute to who you've been here. I've been so honoured. You helped make this happen... you were the first. I can't tell you how grateful I am for you.

It feels somewhat contrived to say, especially given the name of this place, but I feel like Liam's presence ( / lack of it) was at first this raging inferno in me, this thing that could not be ignored. I was walking around, my head shooting sparks and flames. I wanted to scream I AM ON FIRE but I felt like no one would believe me. And now I feel a movement towards where you are, a year and a half later, to what feels more like the kind of embers you'd toast a marshmallow on. And I think perhaps it stays that way, this fire you think is out, most of the time, but that still, somehow, gives off heat and crackle from time to time.

I just loved this so much, Bon. thank you.
February 10, 2009 | Unregistered Commentersweetsalty kate
Thank you, thank you for this post, Bon. And thank you for your presence at glow. Your words have been lifelines and light in dark places.

As you write, "But that was not goodbye...in my heart, I was still saying hello." That's it. That's it exactly.

I haven't said goodbye yet, although I've tried. In spite of all common sense, in spite of knowing it's impossible, I'm still calling out, "Come back. Please, come back." I think saying goodbye will mean that I've accepted the fact of Teddy's death, that while I'll still be deeply sad about it, I will be able to stop crying out for the impossible, that I'll be able to relax my death grip on memory and guilt. Maybe. That's just my best guess and hope for now, though. At not quite six months out, it's very possible that saying goodbye, if/when I manage to do it, will mean something else.
February 10, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterErica
Thank you Bon, and goodbye. You will be so missed here. Your story with Finn has been inspirational to me. Finn being your first, and Hope was my first. I have looked to story's like yours for guidance and reassurance that it can all be ok, that you can survive this. That you will breathe again.
This piece was....stunning. I don't know what else to say about it, I'm practically speecless.
I too have not yet said goodbye. I'm almost at 6 months, (my Hope was born just before your Posey) and it feels like goodbye is letting her go. I have not reached any level of acceptance yet, and i'm not sure when I will. But perhaps with more children and the passing of time, things will become clearer to me, as they have for you.
I hope you are able to keep stopping by, Bon.
February 10, 2009 | Unregistered Commentersally
Goodbye, Bon. Wishing you many wonders in the next phase of life.
February 10, 2009 | Unregistered Commenterwabi
"But it was the rituals of living without him that forced me to acknowledge what I knew, internalize it. Each time I moved forward without him, I let go a little. And I hated that"

Yes, this was the most painful. Moving forward without...is like being slowly torn apart.

"...the quiet sea change where what was once incomprehensible becomes, simply, who you are"

Beautifully, beautifully said.
February 10, 2009 | Unregistered Commenterexcavator
What a beautiful, beautiful post. You will be missed here, your wonderful voice, your wisdom, your words.... Little by little, you do let go, you say goodbye, and so it was for me, over the course of that first year. I think I'd finished saying goodbye before the year was up, but it was all such a blur, each day another one to get through. After three months without him, begging him to please come back, I simply stopped, and turned those words into "I miss you."

Which is where I still am, every day. But less so, now, for life without him, while hard and at times lonely, is sweet as well, full of all the other blessings I've been granted.
February 10, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterVirginia
"But that was not goodbye...in my heart, I was still saying hello." That was exactly me when I saw my son for the first time. I had realized he was gone, but I never had met him, so how could I possibly say goodbye? It was too soon. Then again, no matter at what stage, saying goodbye to your children is always too soon. Part of me has said goodbye, part of me still calls for him in the middle of the night, wishing, aching, pleading, for him to come back. Part of me still expects him to come home.

Goodbye, Bon. I have always enjoyed reading your posts, and I will miss reading your take and perspective on being babylost.
February 11, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterFunsize
Thank you for this beautiful post Bon. I needed to read it today. Lately when I talk about Molly and tell her story I find that I say it with very little emotion. The people listening to me often tear up, but I have gotten to a point where I say the words and don't cry. I am sure it is some stage of grief that I am in or something and may or may not change in time. I too love what you said about the time when they are born/die being more about hello than goodbye. There have been rituals since my baby girl was born and died in April that have in someways helped me to say goodbye (when we buried her and her memorial service). However, in many ways I still struggle with letting go.

I too have a green box and a pile of stuff near it in my room of her things, along with a backet of cards people sent us when she was born/died. I also have a drawer with a book of memories and such. In the beginning I looked at those things more often, but now I shy away from them. I know that to continue my grief and healing process I will need to confront them again one of these days and when I do it will probably be healthy for me. I hope in time I will be able to look through them and find some peace and joy in reliving the life and memory of my daughter. Anyway, reading your post today brought up a lot of emotions for me and I had a good cry. Thank you for sharing and all you have brought to Glow and our blogging community.
February 11, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterKathy
Four years. *sigh* It has been an excruciatingly difficult journey hasn't it? Seeming to pass so slowly and so quickly all at the same time. Four years...April for you...May for me. For me, I think I can honestly say that my goodbye came in that instant I heard Myles cry for the first time. In that moment I felt such a peace come over me...it was almost magical. I still miss them, it's true. But I no longer miss them with an urgency to call them back. I just miss them.

On a personal note, I feel blessed to have found you...to be able to call you my "internet friend" (as my mother says)...to have someone to walk with during the last four years. Thank you. I hope that you always feel peace and love and hope around you wherever you travel.
February 11, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterCatherine
Sometimes I feel like I am outside the normalcy realm in db land, because I am getting closer to this feeling that you have so eloquently written about. Thank you for sharing.
February 11, 2009 | Unregistered Commenterg
A very beautiful post, Bon. A very lovely way to leave us.
February 11, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterNatalie
You leave behind a marvelous place, and a legacy in words.
February 12, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterWhyMommy
My goodbye is something that I can almost feel--like a phantom pain. I can still feel his tiny body against my chest as we shared our first and last skin-to-skin time. When I think of our 6 hours with him after his birth all else fades into a grayish background. It is his tiny weight that I try to feel that says goodbye for me.
February 12, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterJulie
How perfectly beautiful.

I know that shift. It has happened for me too- maybe even awhile ago. I feel some guilt in slipping away. I do feel a responsibility to offer some glimmer of hope to those still in the trenches, but I also need to tend to the life that is all around me. I don't know if I can stand in both places anymore.

You are a treasure, Bon. I am grateful to have met you.
February 12, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterLori
Thank you Bon,

Thank you for your words, love and support. I wish you peace.

With Love,

Carly x
February 13, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterCarly
Thank you Bon. Reading this post has given me hope and I hope that I will experience 'the quiet sea change' at some point in the future.
February 13, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterCatherine
Beautiful post. I wish you well and hope to still "see" you around here occasionally.

I feel like the goodbye ebbs and flows. Sometimes I think I am finished with it, and then I wake up one day and realize that I am not.
February 13, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterCLC
I did in fact say a formal good-bye to Calvin. I held him in my arms as he was removed from life support and for the hour it took for him to take his last breath. However, I'm still struggling with the finality of it all and I find myself searching for some meaning, or a sign that will give me some clarity as to why my son had to die. Truthfully, although we said our formal goodbyes, I have not yet let go. My son is in my thoughts all the time, even when I'm sharing a sweet moment with his twin sister I ache for him. My heart yearns for Calvin with an angst I can't describe, a painful hollow aching in my chest that never seems to go away. I hated having to say goodbye to him, we didn't have enough time together. Maybe that's why I struggle. I too smell his hat, the unwashed sleeper he died in longing for a hint of his essence to take me back to the time when he was snuggled up in my arms as I rocked him, the night before his open heart surgery. The pain keeps me tightly bound to him, I can't let him go when I hurt this much...so perhaps my goodbyes will continue to come in whispers gradually with time as my soul begins to heal. Until then, I need this place and anything that gives me the freedom to say his name without fear of being shunned or silenced. I'm sorry to see you go Bon. But on the other hand, it feels like you are being set free and for that I rejoice with you....
February 14, 2009 | Unregistered Commentermargaret
I keep thinking I've pared way back, and I'm leanly just missing. That I've cut back and accepted so many peripherals, and I've done the hard stuff. I realize the pile of Maddy's things has sat on my dresser for two years, and it's now just a part of my daily intake that I don't even really notice anymore. Sometimes I'm proud of that, sometimes I miss missing her and wonder if i'm doing it right.

sometimes someone says something unintentionally hurtful, and I feel like I'm saying goodbye all over again. You're absolutely right, it's incredibly impossible when hello and goodbye are entangled like that.

Thank you so, so much for being here, writing here. Your thoughts and words never cease to amaze me. You will be missed.
February 14, 2009 | Unregistered Commentertash
Margaret, you wrote this: "I need this place and anything that gives me the freedom to say his name without fear of being shunned or silenced. I'm sorry to see you go Bon. But on the other hand, it feels like you are being set free and for that I rejoice with you...."

That's so lovely. I just wanted to say that, and thank you, and say ditto.
February 14, 2009 | Unregistered Commenterkate
"When the baby dies, the leavetaking comes hand in hand with - or before, or in place of - that first magical hello, and all the anticipation and identity shifts of the parent-to-be are left hanging, shredded, irreconcilable with the fabric visible to the outside world."

I don't know that I have said goodbye yet. I remember in the early months knowing I should say goodbye and not being able to do so. But it has been nearly 2 1/2 years now. Goodbye comes in pieces.

I pulled out her blanket a week or so ago and all it smelled like was my cedar chest :(

Thank-you for sharing.
February 15, 2009 | Unregistered Commenterkimberlee
thank you bon for all of your beautiful words. you have been an incredible support to me, to us in these last 5 months since we lost silas. every single post you have written has brought me to tears, you just get it, and write about it so eloquently.
i can't imagine ever being ready to say goodbye to silas, especially since there really was never a hello. i want the passing of time to heal me, but i also hate the idea that i'm getting further and further from having held him in my arms, or having him inside me.
much love xo
February 15, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterLani

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.